Though Israel’s ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students have long been exempt from military service, they weren’t always. In the struggle to secure what became the Jewish state, this camp’s rabbis and public figures were clear that their followers had to fight for Israel’s independence alongside everyone else
The Council of Great Sages (Moetzet Gedolei Ha-Torah), which governs Israel’s ultra-Orthodox sector, has traditionally opposed Zionism and boycotted Zionist institutions. However, during the feverish international negotiations leading up to the United Nations vote awarding the Jewish people a country, this rabbinical body joined forces with the rest of the Jewish community in the land of Israel. That’s partly because the rabbis were wooed by the Jewish Agency, which effectively ran the Zionist state in the making and presumed to represent the entire Jewish population.
Once the establishment of the state was inevitable, the ultra-Orthodox resolved to influence from within rather than remain outsiders, especially given the dangers facing the Jewish community in Mandate Palestine. With the Jewish people as a whole still reeling from the Holocaust, and displaced Jews uncertain of their final destination, there seemed only one realistic solution. A Jewish state would shelter all these homeless and eliminate assimilation, ensuring Judaism’s survival.
Safety and Security
In October 1947, the executive council of World Agudath Israel – representing the ultra-Orthodox – set up an emergency committee in Mandate Palestine to consult with the Council of Great Sages. Other issues would be addressed to a smaller council of scholars, who would confer with four senior rabbis from Jerusalem: Yosef Zvi Dushinsky; Isser Zalman Meltzer, dean of Etz Hayim Yeshiva; Yitzhak Zev Soloveitchik (the Brisker Rav); and Akiva Sofer-Schreiber.
On November 29, 1947, some three weeks before the UN vote to partition Palestine, the executive committee of the Council of Great Sages decided that Aguda (as the movement is abbreviated) would not work against the establishment of a Jewish state. Furthermore, the committee undertook
To send representatives of Aguda to the security committee [of the Jewish Agency] purely for safety and security purposes, with no ramifications regarding other places and branches of the Jewish Agency and the Jewish National Council, to which no representatives will be sent at present. (Agudat Yisrael Archive [Hebrew])
The hostilities following the UN decision prevented the executive committee from meeting and authorizing further measures. Two weeks later, during Hanukka, four members of the Council of Great Sages determined that Aguda representatives should present the army recruitment committee with their conditions for supporting enlistment. These four rabbis – Meltzer, Zalman Sorotzkin, Meir Karelitz, and the Hasidic Master of Sadigor, Avraham Yaakov Friedman – also formulated their requirements for allowing their community to join the military. These included an exemption for women and – temporarily at least – yeshiva students, no training on the Sabbath and festivals, and separate units for religious soldiers, allowing them to remain strictly observant during their army service. All these conditions were accepted by the committee.

Endorsing Enlistment
Aguda fliers and newspaper ads soon called on members to enlist, stipulating that doing so wouldn’t compromise their religious values. This campaign was addressed to the rank and file rather than yeshiva students, whose recruitment was still under discussion. Aguda constituents promptly arrived in droves for medical examinations prior to becoming combat soldiers. Ultra-Orthodox organizations took care of all their religious needs, troubleshooting each new issue as it surfaced.
Young Aguda (Agudat Yisrael’s youth organization) encouraged ultra-Orthodox youngsters to join the struggle for the prestate Jewish community’s survival, choosing an army service tailored to their religious lifestyle. Special editions of Young Aguda’s Diglenu (Our Flag) newspaper were geared toward them, and the organization also published a Letter to Soldiers periodically. Young Aguda’s Jerusalem branch even printed its own Letter to Soldiers when the city was under siege.
Aguda dailies and journals urged Jerusalemites to enlist at recruitment centers designated for the ultra-Orthodox. These appeals included glowing descriptions of army exercises and accounts of battle conditions. Journalists praised those who’d already signed up, with one Aguda paper even enthusing:
Our aim is not just to take care of Jewish dietary issues, but a much higher purpose: to return to the ancient and original form of warfare we once practiced against our enemies. These young men’s bravery and actions will sanctify the name of Heaven. (Ha-yoman, 19 Adar I 5708/February 29, 1948)

Yeshiva Regiment
As recruitment expanded, exemption criteria narrowed. Students in college, university, or post-high-school yeshiva programs were generally the perfect recruits. On the other hand, inasmuch as these young people were the future of the country, their needs had to be taken into account. After meeting with the directors of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem on February 16, 1948, David Ben-Gurion, as chairman of the Jewish Agency’s, declared:
Every student engaged in scientific research for military purposes will not be discharged from such work or deployed anywhere else. Other students should not be excused [from army service] completely, but some kind of continuity in their studies should be attempted, to the extent possible. (David Ben-Gurion, War Diary, 1948–1949, vol. 1 [Ministry of Defense, 1982], pp. 248–49 [Hebrew])
Jerusalem commander David Shaltiel thus gave university students defending Gush Etzion daily breaks to resume their studies.
Meanwhile, the Recruitment Census Office for National Service was negotiating with yeshiva deans regarding their students. Chief Rabbi Isaac Halevi Herzog’s archive includes a letter from the census office dated 2 Adar I 5708 (February 12, 1948) and detailing an acceptance “with understanding” of the deans’ request to defer student enlistment for three months, pending further review at that time.
As Arab armies were expected to invade the new state once the British Mandate ended, a state of emergency was declared on May 1, 1948, and all enlistment exemptions were cancelled in the Jerusalem area. This unilateral decision incensed the city’s ultra-Orthodox, and a new round of negotiation with yeshiva deans began. Ten days later, an agreement governing the draft and release of yeshiva students was finalized.
During May 16–28, nine hundred yeshiva students presented themselves at the Jerusalem recruitment office created for them. Some 270 – including Holocaust survivors and others suffering from malnutrition – were excused for health reasons. Another 260 – outstanding young rabbis and scholars – were exempt as per the agreement. The remaining 370 were deemed fit to serve.
Fierce battles were already raging in the Jerusalem area, especially after the Jordanian Arab Legion joined the fray on May 19. With neither time nor ammunition to train the yeshiva students, they were put to work sandbagging, building fences, digging shelters, and the like. Tuvia Bir led the group, known as Tuvia’s Regiment, and company commanders were selected from among the new recruits. Their rabbis were in constant contact and produced a monthly newsletter, Ha-mivtzar (The Fortress), distributed to other religious units as well.
His opposition to an exemption for yeshiva students swayed his colleagues. Rabbi Isaac Halevi Herzog, Jerusalem, 1945 | Photo: Zoltan Kluger, Israel National Photo Collection
Like prestate health and welfare, enlistment was organized along party lines. Aguda poster urging members to join the army | IDF Archive
Reaching a Compromise
Tuvia’s Regiment was actually the result of a compromise owing much to the urgency and sensitivities of the hour. On December 29, 1947, Rabbi Herzog, whose opinion carried weight with his ultra-Orthodox colleagues, had written a detailed, forty-eight-page halakhic responsum touching on issues raised by the integration of yeshiva students into the army at this crucial time. The shadow of the Holocaust only exacerbated the conflict between the physical defense of the Jewish community in the land of Israel, which had absorbed a large proportion of Europe’s surviving Jews, and the need to protect what remained of the spiritual legacy of Europe’s Torah institutions, most of which had been destroyed. Rabbi Herzog concluded that the Torah itself would define the current war as obligatory, i.e., an existential battle from which no Jew – even a scholar – was exempt. Nonetheless, he wrote::
[…] we must be careful not to undermine the continued practice of Torah learning, Heaven forfend, even briefly, particularly now, when all the Diaspora centers of learning have been destroyed and all that remains is the scholarship of the land of Israel. (“On the Issue of Yeshiva Students in Respect of Our Situation,” Rabbi Dr. Yitzhak Isaac Halevi Herzog Archive, Israel State Archives, p. 46 [Hebrew])
Rabbi Herzog noted that it was the yeshiva deans’ responsibility to arrange full exemption for truly outstanding students and part-time service under special conditions for the rest. He added that participation in the war effort would diminish the general population’s growing antagonism toward the ultra-Orthodox. Herzog suggested that the community seek a compromise similar to the one applying to university students serving in the army, who were granted a few hours off each day to study. After all, Ben-Gurion considered advanced secular education essential to the new state, but he also understood that Torah study was essential to the religious community. With not a little persuasion by Rabbi Herzog, the yeshiva deans and Rabbi Yosef Zvi Dushinsky signed the chief rabbi’s proposed agreement.
This arrangement was possible largely because of yeshiva students’ admiration and enthusiasm for – and in some cases, participation in – the underground militias fighting the British prior to the state. As these forces were now incorporated into the army, their ultra-Orthodox fighters were automatically enlisted too. Shulamit Ezrahi, daughter of Rabbi Meyer Hadash, student dean of Hebron Yeshiva, described how Arab attacks left students torn between Torah study and national defense, and how her father took their feelings into account. Two enlisted men studied in the Sefat Emet Yeshiva (affiliated with the Ger Hasidic sect) and fought in the bitter battle for Motza, in the Jerusalem Corridor, in March 1948. Hayim Grub was just sixteen when he fell in combat, and a fellow student was wounded.

Supporting the Troops
The special nature of the ultra-Orthodox troops required a whole system catering to their needs. Rabbi Hanokh (Henikh) Padua was appointed to rule on any halakhic questions; Rabbi Efrayim Ofenberg ensured the religious rights of soldiers in the Jerusalem vicinity (kosher food, prayer breaks, Sabbath and festival observance, etc.). David Eisen was responsible for dietary and other requirements for an ultra-Orthodox group training in Arza, just outside the city.

Rallies were held for these soldiers both before and during their army service, with members of the Council of Torah Sages and other senior ultra-Orthodox figures on hand to give their blessing. Religious leaders from Haifa, including Rabbi Barukh Hager, the Seret-Vizhnitz Rebbe, attended a send-off for new recruits in February 1948; Hager was also a guest of honor, together with Ponovezh Yeshiva dean Rabbi Shlomo Yosef Kahaneman of Bnei Brak, at a Hanukka gathering for over three hundred ultra-Orthodox soldiers in Haifa in December 1949.
Back in March 1948, a vacation retreat for religious troops had opened in Bnei Brak on the grounds of an urban kibbutz. The place hosted its first group of fighters on Purim, free of charge. Despite wartime shortages countrywide, Orthodox soldiers received Pesach gift packages. On Pesach, free, public Seder meals were provided for off-duty soldiers. Young Aguda’s Letter for Soldiers that summer included messages both to and from these troops.
A festive gathering for Aguda-affiliated troops was held at Young Aguda’s Tel Aviv clubhouse on the second day of Rosh Hashana in 1948. The movement also sponsored Sukkot celebrations for soldiers in Bnei Brak, Petah Tikva, and Netanya that year. Army officers affiliated with Aguda were honored side by side with Young Aguda leaders.
Clearly, the defense establishment of the emerging state aimed to fulfill the Council of Sages’ requirements. The military even set up a Religious Service division, with its senior ranks filled by ultra-Orthodox representatives. In practice, however, commanders were sometimes ignorant and unaccommodating, and many soldiers encountered challenges to Sabbath observance and dietary restrictions.
In the few cases where matters couldn’t be resolved and complaints were filed, the plaintiffs were provided with legal counsel, and Aguda brought these incidents to government as well as parliamentary attention.
Today’s Israeli army is both strictly kosher and observant of Jewish holidays (within the bounds of military necessity) partly because, in 1948, state institutions and the ultra-Orthodox briefly recognized their interdependence. Overall, however, the experimental integration of ultra-Orthodox soldiers failed. They encountered too many problems for their leadership to allow it to continue. Nevertheless, that brief period of unity, and the relatively large numbers of religious Zionist and ultra-Orthodox soldiers enlisting, forged an awareness and accommodation of Jewish religious observance that was by no means a given in the largely secular militias that preceded the state. The existence ever since of a Religious Service within the Israel Defense Forces has helped make the army a melting pot for Israeli society, uniting all walks of life.
Photo: IDF Archive, Bir Family Archive
Photo: Central Zionist Archives
Photo: Poalei Agudat Yisrael Archive
Ultra-Orthodox newspapers geared toward soldiers, produced by Young Aguda and Tuvia’s Regiment




